Fish Fry Reviews - The Complete List

Early in 2022, we went to Quivey’s Grove for a Fish Fry, and we both walked away saying it was the best one we had ever had. This inspired me to start tracking and rating all of the fish we try. I love a good fish fry– give me some beer battered fish any day of the week! Here’s our list so far, and I will keep it updated for you!

Baraboo Burger Company

116 4th Ave, Baraboo, WI 53913

The Menu Description: Guinness Beer Battered Cod served with a choice of side, coleslaw, breadstick, and tartar.

Our Description: When it is served you can tell that it was frozen by its appearance, but I was pleasantly surprised by the batter! It has a thick, crispy layer and great flavor. One thing BBC always does great is their portion size– So much food!

Hayden: (it has been too long for him. Will re-try and come back with a score)

Julia: B

Check out our Baraboo Travel Guide: Baraboo Visitors Guide - #NotTheDells

Beach Club on Madeline Island

817 Fort Rd, La Pointe, WI 54850

The Menu Description: Fresh Caught Lake Superior Whitefish, prepared breaded. Severed with French Fries, house made tartar, and coleslaw.

Our Description: Sit outside and dine right on Lake Superior. The fish isn’t battered which I prefer, but the breading was still so crispy. It definitely tasted fresh!

Julia: B+

Visiting the Bayfield?: Bayfield, WI Travel Guide

Bent’s Camp

6882 S Helen Creek Rd, Land O' Lakes, WI 54540

The Menu Description: 3 or 5 pieces of deep fried haddock with french fries, potato salad, coleslaw, beans, lemon, & tartar sauce.

Our Description: This is such a legendary Wisconsin resort, bar, and restaurant and on my very first visit I understood why. It is the definition of Northwoods vibes. Grab a cocktail, order a fish fry and kick back on their lovely dog-friendly patio, or grassy picnic tables overlooking the chain of lakes.

Julia: B+

Check out out Northwoods blog: DOGS IN THE NORTHWOODS

Bootleggers Lodge

2001 Indian Pine Point Rd, Tomahawk, WI 54487

The Menu Description: Beer Battered Cod

Our Description: It is served with a light crispy batter that has remarkable flavor! It comes with apple sauce, potato pancakes, coleslaw, and tartar. I recommend a reservation if you are looking to do dinner. I was by myself and ate at the bar. My food came so quickly.

Julia: A-

Check out out Northwoods blog: DOGS IN THE NORTHWOODS

Broadway Diner

304 Broadway St, Baraboo, WI 53913

The Menu Description: Hand battered cod served with choice of potato and our homemade coleslaw

Our Description: This beer batter is so great–think light fluffy batter! It could have been crispier, but I also really enjoyed the super savory potato pancakes

Julia: B+

Check out our Baraboo Travel Guide: Baraboo Visitors Guide - #NotTheDells

Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club

7700 Harwood Ave, Wauwatosa, WI 53213

The Menu Description: Beer-battered fish (choice of perch, haddock, or pan-fried walleye) served with potato pancakes, apple sauce, tartar sauce, buttermilk coleslaw, rye bread, and lemon

Our Description: The vibe of this place is cool! It is a staged supper club! Makes you feel like you’re in the Northwoods even though you are in the city. The food looks so pretty! I liked the potato pancakes. They were super crispy! I got the perch and it was very, very salty. Hayden got the pan-fried walleye.

Hayden: A

Julia: C+

Commerce Street Brewing

23 Commerce St, Mineral Point, WI 53565

The Menu Description: Two pieces of crispy, tempura-battered cod with hand-cut, seasoned french fries and carrot salad.

Our Description: This light crispy batter was so good!!

Hayden: A-

Julia: A-

Plan the perfect visit: MINERAL POINT TRAVEL GUIDE

Dorf Haus

8931 County Hwy Y, Sauk City, WI 53583

The Menu Description: Lightly breaded and deep fried. Served with German potato salad, French Fries, or baked potato, coleslaw, and fritters.

Our Description: The wait can be long, but the Fritters are worth the wait! They serve warm fritters with honey butter that will keep me coming back! The breading is very thin, but has a good flavor.

Hayden: B

Julia: B

Downtowner

130 3rd St, Baraboo, WI 53913

The Menu Description: Breaded cod with fries, homemade coleslaw and Texas toast

Our Description: Super crispy and has a shrimp add on. Also comes as a fish sandwich. Our hometown bar!

Hayden: B+

Julia: B

Check out our Baraboo Travel Guide: Baraboo Visitors Guide - #NotTheDells

The Fat Seagull

807 Quay St, Manitowoc, WI 54220

The Menu Description: Perch or walleye plate: Fish fry entrees include choice of potato salad or fries, coleslaw, and rye bread

Our Description: We enjoyed a walleye fish fry. The fish was breaded and crispy and the patio had live music to enjoy. The lobster bisque came highly recommended, and it must be good, because it was already sold out when we arrived at 7pm. We’ll definitely be back for the bisque, but make sure you learn from our mistake and get there early!!

Hayden: B

Julia: B+

Head to Manitowoc: Manitowoc Travel Guide: Dog-Friendly

Fish Tales

W12690 WI-188, Lodi, WI 53555

The Menu Description: Potato & Cheddar Crusted Cod – two piece baked cod crusted with potato and cheddar. Walleye Pike – beer battered or broiled. Deep Fried Lake Perch – lightly hand-breaded, seasoned and deep fried. Deep Fried Bluegill – lightly hand-breaded, seasoned and deep fried.

Icelandic Haddock –beer battered

Our Description: They have lots of choices! The atmosphere is great. The patio is right on Lake Wisconsin… take the free ferry across the lake! I love the beer battered walleye! It comes with potato pancakes and tartar.

Hayden: A-

Julia: A-

Lodi is an Ice Age Trail community! Here's what you need to know: All Things Ice Age Trail

Green Acres

7487 WI-78 Trunk, Sauk City, WI 53583

The Menu Description: A Wisconsin Friday tradition! Haddock served with french fries or baked potato & coleslaw.

Our Description: This old school supper club has great food options and the fish fry is no exception! The fish has a thick, beer batter that is perfectly crispy! The sides are very lack luster, but you should try the french onion soup.

Hayden: B+

Julia: B+

Hi Point Steakhouse

6900 Co Rd HHH, Ridgeway, WI 53582

The Menu Description: Friday Fish Fry

Our Description: Light, thin, and crispy batter. Solid fish fry, but nothing earth shattering. If it is being featured, be sure to get the Seafood Wellington. It is so good! The French Onion soup is also great.

Julia: B

Hillsboro Berwing Compnay

206 E Madison St, Hillsboro, WI 54634

The Menu Description: Tempura Battered Cod fillets with house-made tartar sauce, beer fries, and coleslaw

Our Description: They have a fun atmosphere and are a great space for groups. We thought the fish was great! It came with super crispy light batter. When we were there one of the features was fish tacos that came with churro cheesecake, but they never brought us our cheesecakes. When we inquired about it they let us know that it was sold out, which was a bummer. Not our best service experience, but still enjoyed the brews and the fish itself.

Hayden: A-

Julia: B

Honey Bear

5430 WI-70, Eagle River, WI 54521

The Menu Description: 3 pieces of North Atlantic Cod - Tender and flakey beer batter cod filets. Our traditional Honey Bear fish fry.

Our Description: I was in a little bit of sticker shock looking at the menu. Their Honey Bear Fish Fry was $21. That felt a bit steep to us, but when we got our order it was a big portion: 3 large pieces of beer battered cod that was nice and crispy, a side–get the potato salad, and rye bread. It was yummy, but I don’t feel the need to go back for it again due to the high price.

Hayden: B+ (but the potato salad got an A!)

Julia: B+

Need a weekend getaway?: Escape to the Wisconsin Northwoods

The Keg & Patio

732 Oak St, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965

The Menu Description: Beer battered or broiled cod. Served with coleslaw & choice of french fries or baked potato. 2 piece or 3 piece

Our Description: Thin beer batter with good flavor. Great patio dining!

Hayden: B

Julia: B

Looking for more than waterparks?: Dogs In The Dells

Lakefront Brewery

1872 N Commerce St, Milwaukee, WI 53212

The Menu Description: Fish Fry Dinner: 3-piece beer battered cod with choice of side. Fried Walleye Dinner: Hand breaded crispy walleye filets served with choice of side. Combo Dinner: Beer-battered cod, breaded walleye and fried shrimp. Served with choice of side and wasabi cocktail sauce. (no substitutions)

Our Description: Be sure you get the cheese curds to start! They are so good and have a great cheese pull. You should also get the Lakefront Rootbeer Ol’ Fashioned– so unique and so good! Fish fry has a great batter that is super crispy with yummy flavor. They also have great sides.

Hayden: B

Julia: A

Mars Resort

W4098 S Shore Dr, Lake Geneva, WI 53147

The Menu Description: Mars Famous Fish Fry: Served with lemon, butter or our homemade tartar sauce Choice of soup, salad or coleslaw. Choice of potato, vegetable or homemade corn fritters

Our Description: The fish was okay. The breading lacked flavor for me. I got the fritters and they were very over cooked. Hayden loved the swordfish special and definitely wait for your table with a cocktail at the beach!

Julia: C

Check out our guide to Lake Geneva: LAKE GENEVA WEEKEND GETAWAY

Minocqua Yacht Club

8290 US-51, Minocqua, WI 54548

The Menu Description: Beer battered walleye or haddock. Served with rye bread, coleslaw, baked beans, and your choice of fries, or potato salad.

Our Description: Sit on the water and enjoy this massive portion of crispy fish.

Julia: B+

Check out out Northwoods blog: DOGS IN THE NORTHWOODS

Pickled Herring

1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

The Menu Description: Voted Top 10 in Wisconsin. Deep Fried fresh Bayfield Whitefish with choice of side.

Our Description: They have an awesome breaded fish fry, a huge dessert selection, and fun Old Fashioneds.

Julia: B+

Visiting the Bayfield?: Bayfield, WI Travel Guide

Pier 290

1 Liechty Dr, Williams Bay, WI 53191

The Menu Description: Lightly flour dusted for a delicate crispy coating. Served with roasted potatoes and roasted seasonal vegetables

Our Description: Not a typical fish fry because it is pan fried, but it is so good! This place was one of our favorite dates of the year. We loved the French Onion soup and the cobbler for dessert.

Julia: A-

Check out our guide to Lake Geneva: LAKE GENEVA WEEKEND GETAWAY

Quivey’s Grove

6261 Nesbitt Rd, Fitchburg, WI 53719

The Menu Description: Friday Fish Fry Served with choice of Parmesan Potato or French fries, coleslaw, and fresh baked muffins

Our Description: This was THE best fish fry we have ever had! Be sure to make a reservation for the Stone House. We both gave this meal an A and that never happens. The fish fry came with warm blueberry muffins— Hayden found this so strange, but I found it to be a unique “homemade” touch! Plus, they were SO GOOD, he couldn’t even deny it. Hayden ordered the nightly special, which was crab stuffed cod, but he much preferred my fried fish. It was so light, crispy, and full of flavor! I couldn’t speak more highly of it. As their menu says: “Some restaurants are IN Wisconsin, Quivey’s Grove IS Wisconsin.”

Hayden: A

Julia: A+

The Rock

101 Maple Ave, Beloit, WI 53511

The Menu Description: Beer Battered Cod: Coleslaw and your choice of potato: choice of chips, French Fries, mashed, or Potato Pancakes

Our Description: Sit on their beautiful patio overlooking the Rock River. Great crisp on the fish!

Hayden: B+

Julia: B+

Check out Beloit's Glow Up!: Dog-Friendly Weekend Getaway - Beloit, WI

River Walk Pub

911 River Rd, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965

The Menu Description: Hand-breaded cod

Our Description: This was a pretty lackluster fish fry for me. I thought the sweet potato fries were mushy and the fish wasn’t crispy.

Julia: C

Looking for more than waterparks?: Dogs In The Dells

Tumbled Rock Brewery

S5718 State Rd 136 & DL, S5718 State Rd 123, Baraboo, WI 53913

The Menu Description: An 8 to 9 ounce portion of a Wisconsin fish fry classic. Served with potato. Sugar snap peas. Coleslaw. Rye dinner roll & butter.

Our Description: Great flavor, crispy, beer battered fish. Be sure to order the French Onion soup here. It is so good!

Hayden: B

Julia: A-

Check out our Baraboo Travel Guide: Baraboo Visitors Guide - #NotTheDells

841 Brewhouse

841 E Milwaukee St, Whitewater, WI 53190

The Menu Description: House beer battered filet of Atlantic cod topped with Wisconsin cheddar cheese. Served with a side of tartar sauce.

Our Description: This fish was so good! The batter on the fish is so thick, but still crispy! Seriously so yummy!

Julia: A-

Get out and explore: Weekend in Whitewater